Energetics in daemonic work extraction protocols via non-ideal QND-energy measurement

Abstract

We address the problem of extracting work from a quantum system assisted by a quantum non-demolition (QND) energy measurement. When a perfect QND measurement can be performed and an auxiliary zero-temperature bath is available, the full energy of the quantum state can in principle be extracted even without any prior information on the input state. Owing to the presence of a zero-temperature bath, this is achieved at no energetic cost for the measurement process itself. On the contrary, here we consider what happens when the same protocol is implemented in non-ideal scenarios, specifically when the auxiliary bath has a finite temperature. In this case, not only is it impossible to extract the entire energy from the system, but the measurement strategy also acquires a non-zero energetic cost, accounting for both the interaction between system and measurement apparatus, and the corresponding Landauer erasure cost. We quantitatively assess the performance of these work-extraction protocols, both in absolute terms and through the so-called daemonic net gain, which explicitly includes the energetic cost of the measurement. We rigorously prove that, when access to a thermal bath is allowed in the extraction protocol, the daemonic net gain is always non-positive for any temperature of the auxiliary bath. Conversely, when only unitary operations are considered, the daemonic net gain can attain positive values. We further discuss these different figures of merit by analyzing a paradigmatic example for a single qubit system.